To Thine Own Self Be No Stooge

July 20, 2011

Adam Smith suggested that one major tactic of business was to deceive and oppress the public. Smith (1723-1790), has been called the father of modern economics and capitalism. His idea was that in pursuing one’s own good a person unintentionally contributed to the good of society. With that awareness all business had to do was to manipulate an individual’s intention to pursue his or her own good in order to herd the mass of people for its own monetary advantage.

“It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker, that we expect our dinner,” Adams said, “but from their regard to their own interest. We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities but of their advantages.”

“… never talk to them of our own necessities…”  In other words, never talk to them of the fortunes we can make by our manipulation of them. With the prevalence of phenomena such as death-by-Philip Morris we can see that Smith knew what he was talking about.

In a conversation between Noam Chomsky and Robert Trivers at Seed Magazine Chomsky noted a well-known and accepted instrument of deceit employed by corporations.  He said, “… one of the striking features of the modern period is the institutionalization of (deceit), so that we … have huge industries deceiving the public …— the public relations industry.”

Of course this is not exactly earth-shattering news. The practice of public relations is so common we’ve come to accept corporate deceit as a given, as a result it goes pretty much unnoticed and unremarked. It’s as invisible and comfortably sleep-inducing in American life as carbon monoxide in a closed car.

In fact, Chomsky and Trivers suggest that self-deception is a significant condition of modern life; death-by-Philip Morris is just one example (death-by-fossil-fuel burning is another). The interplay of deception and self-deception required to induce a person (usually a young one) to start smoking, especially now when the effects of smoking are so well known, is founded upon both poles of deception.

In death-by-Philip Morris the gamut of deception and self-deception range from cigarette manufacturing execs to consumers. Manufacturers deceive themselves into thinking it’s morally acceptable to accumulate fortunes selling a product known to kill —of luring children into addiction to their product thereby potentially killing them— and to lie for years that their product was safe. While at the other end of the self-deceit spectrum are those who begin smoking out of ignorance and continue with an unrealistic certainty of invulnerability summed up in the idea that “it won’t happen to me” until reality kicks in with a diagnosis of lung cancer.

As Chomsky observes, “I mean, I think we all know from personal life, if there’s something you want to do, it’s really easy to convince yourself it’s right and just. You put away evidence that shows that’s not true.”

It was just this kind of deception that led us into a war of choice that has cost huge loss of life and billions of dollars and contributed to the financial debacle we now find ourselves in. And it’s been this kind of deception (served up by Wall Street through the mouths of conservatives) that has produced the highest unemployment rate in the last twenty years. It’s a deception so deep that politicians like Eric Cantor, John Boehner, and Mitch McConnell keep repeating the tax-cuts-bring-jobs mantra despite the absolutely clear evidence that the Bush tax cuts (which are still in effect) have not created jobs but have instead sucked them right out of the country!  If tax cuts created jobs so many Americans should not be un-voluntarily out of work.

Finally, it’s the kind of deception and self-deception (of myopic ideologues like Cantor, Paul Ryan, and their hostage, John Boehner) that has for weeks had the government of the U.S. focused not on job creation but on putting one man out of a job, namely Barak Obama. If, by means of refusing to raise the US debt ceiling Mitch McConnell believes he’s found the modus of  his primary function as a senator: to run Obama out of the White House (which he has proudly avowed) —  if he believes that’s more important than creating jobs he’s one self-deluded dude.

Though deception and self-deception love to tango, and have through the ages, and have with wild passion most recently in the U.S, there are hopeful signs that self-deception is becoming exhausted.

Though deception persists in the likes of politicians such as Mitch McConnell and Governors like Wisconsin’s Scott Warner; and in the board rooms of Wall Street and freak shows like Michelle Bachmann, there’s a sense that the people are tired of lying to themselves. In Wisconsin, for instance, Republican maneuvering to confuse voters in state elections to recall Republican reps has proven a failure. Wisconsin voters have rejected Republican efforts to dirty-trick the vote their way.

Before we as a nation can climb out of the political swamp we find ourselves in we’ve got to dump the self-deceit that leads us to believe what the evidence clearly disproves. If, for example, a politician says that cutting taxes for the wealthy creates jobs, and taxes for the wealthy were cut in 2001 but since then unemployment has risen; and if those cuts are still in effect and corporation heads are pocketing billions while the unemployment rate goes up, then it’s time to stop lying to yourself that such politicians are honest brokers for your interests.

“Above all,” Shakespeare said, “to thine own self be true, and it must follow, as the night they day, thou canst not be false to any man.”

To thine own self at least
be no stooge
and things may change

by Jim Culleny
for The Shelburne Falls Independent, 7/21/11


3 Responses to “To Thine Own Self Be No Stooge”

  1. david levandusky Says:

    Jim: In all your explaining of why the Republicans should not be cutting taxes you have not clearly explained how to get rid of the trillions of dollars of debt our children and grandchildren are inheriting each time the debt ceiling is raised. It matters not to me who is responsible for the trillions of dollars of debt. I want the solution to bringing the debt down and balancing the budget. Of course I want to know how I can pay my credit card off too.

  2. Jim Says:

    Dave if we started here we might make headway:

    Dump Bush tax cuts for the rich and tax them at the rates they were taxed in the 1970s, at least. (70%).

    I know, I know, the new name for the rich coined by Republicans is “Job Creators” and, according to the stooges of the rich, “Job Creators” would not be creating jobs if their tax rate was so high.
    But that runs counter to the history (especially recent history) of the U.S. They were creating more jobs when they were paying 70%.

    Further, since the Bush tax cuts are still operative and since they have been for the last 10 years, and since unemployment has risen steadily during that period and since people are still out of work involuntarily I’d say the Republicans are doing what they usually do in behalf of money: making things up.

    Make corporate financing of elections absolutely illegal. Despite the Supreme Court campaign “donations” are not “speech”. Speech is something that exits the mouth not that enters the pocket. Instead tax corporations to pay for all election campaigns (to be distributed equally among contenders).

    Index the salaries of all senators, congressional reps and the president to the average wage rates of American workers. Then anyone who served would more likely be working in the interests of the American people.

    Have their pensions keyed to rates of their year in government.

    Take them off their health care plan and have them buy their own as average American currently have to.

    Make it illegal for anyone who’s been a lobbyist to qualify for national office for 20 years after thier last lobbying job. And make it illegal for senators, congressional reps and presidents to become lobbyists for 20 years after leaving office.

    There’s more, but this would be start.

    If these things were put into place I’d be more willing to at least consider ideas that would hurt the poor and middle class.

    The poor will always be with us, because the rich are always with us.

  3. david levandusky Says:

    Perhaps your plan Jim would help our country to stop adding about 4 billion dollars everyday to our National debt. Adding to the debt ceiling is like me adding to my credit card bill that I cannot pay off. Got to stop buying stuff and adding it to my credit card bill. But the good news is I just got a letter from my credit card company informing my that I have been chosen because of good credit rating and they will raise my credit card limit. Just think – they will let me go into further debt because of my good credit rating. Sounds like the U.S. doesn’t it with its AAA credit rating. Raise the debt ceiling and keep on spending – makes for prosperous economy. The Bible says , “The borrower is servant to the lender.” That’s why countries like China like us. WE are their servant.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: